Determination of the indoor air bacterial load and associated factors in primary schools in Hawassa City, Ethiopia, 2023. A comparative cross-sectional study
Keywords:
Bacterial Load, Contributing Factors, Classrooms, Indoor Air, Settle PlateAbstract
Background: Indoor environments, particularly in schools, are a significant source of bacterial exposure, posing a public health risk. The aim of this study was to investigate the bacterial load and associated factors in the indoor environments of governmental and private primary schools in Hawassa, City, Ethiopia, 2023.
Methods: A comparative cross-sectional study design was used in March, 2023; in 56 randomly selected classrooms focusing in five governmental and five private primary schools in Hawassa, City. The bacterial load was estimated using the settle-plate method of passive air sampling. Differences in the mean bacterial load between government and private primary schools were evaluated using a non-parametric test. Multiple linear regression analysis using log-transformed data was performed.
Result: The average bacterial load in government primary schools was 8684.84 CFU/m3; while in private schools, it was 4396.43 CFU/m3. The isolated bacterial species included coagulase-negative Staphylococcus species (CoNS), gram-negative Bacillus species, gram-positive Bacillus species, and Staphylococcus aureus. A significant difference in the mean bacterial load (p=0.002) was observed between government and private primary schools with private primary schools showing lower levels. In government schools, the bacterial load was significantly associated with classroom cleanliness, occupant density, cleaning frequency, and classroom area. Conversely, the bacterial load in private schools showed strong association with the occupant density, cleaning frequency, relative humidity, and ventilation conditions.
Conclusion: In government and private primary schools, the level of bacterial loads exceeded the WHO criteria. This study revealed significant differences in indoor bacterial loads between government and private primary schools, with private schools showing lower levels. The correlation between bacterial load and environmental factors was distinct in each setting. As a recommendation; improving cleanliness, layout optimization, ventilation improvement, and hygiene education for both sectors, with regular air quality monitoring are crucial for tracking progress.
References
1. World Health Organization. WHO guidelines for indoor air quality: selected pollutants. Geneva: WHO; 2010.
2. Al Mijalli SH. Bacterial contamination of indoor air in schools of Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Air Water Borne Dis 2017;6:1-8.
3. Hayleeyesus SF, Manaye AM. Microbiological quality of indoor air in university libraries. Asian Pac J Trop Biomed 2014;4:S312-7.
4. Toyinbo OO. Indoor environmental quality, pupils’ health and academic performance. Joensuu: University of Eastern Finland; 2017.
5. Gizaw Z, Gebrehiwot M, Yenew C. High bacterial load of indoor air in hospital wards: the case of University of Gondar teaching hospital, Northwest Ethiopia. Multidiscip Respir Med 2016;11:1-7.
6. Brągoszewska E, Mainka A, Pastuszka JS, Lizończyk K, Desta YG. Assessment of bacterial aerosol in a preschool, primary school and high school in Poland. Atmosphere 2018;9:87.
7. Brągoszewska E, Mainka A, Pastuszka JS. Bacterial and fungal aerosols in rural nursery schools in Southern -Poland. Atmosphere 2016;7:142.
8. Dick A, Wekhe C. Microbial indoor air quality in a secondary school in Port Harcourt City, Rivers State, Nigeria. J Appl Sci Environ Manag 2020;24:1289-92.
9. Ashrafi-Asgarabad A, Bokaie S, Razmyar J, Akbarein H, Nejadghaderi SA, Carson-Chahhoud K, et al. The burden of lower respiratory infections and their underlying etiologies in the Middle East and North Africa region,
1990–2019: results from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2019. BMC Pulm Med 2023;23:2.
10. Heseltine E, Rosen J. WHO guidelines for indoor air -quality: dampness and mould. Geneva: WHO; 2009.
11. Mohan K, Madhan N, Ramprasad S, Maruthi Y. Microbiological air quality of indoors in primary and secondary schools of Visakhapatnam, India. Int J Curr Microbiol App Sci 2014;3:880-7.
12. Enitan S, Ihongbe J, Ochei J, Effedua H, Adeyemi O, -Phillips T. Microbiological assessment of indoor air quality of some selected private primary schools in -Ilishan-Remo, Ogun state, Nigeria. Int J Med Health Res 2017;3:8-19.
13. Burroughs H, Hansen SJ. Managing indoor air quality. Aalborg: River Publishers; 2020.
14. Andualem Z, Gizaw Z, Dagne H. Indoor culturable fungal load and associated factors among public primary school classrooms in Gondar City, Northwest Ethiopia, 2018: a cross-sectional study. Ethiop J Health Sci 2019;29.
15. Andualem Z, Gizaw Z, Bogale L, Dagne H. Indoor bacterial load and its correlation to physical indoor air quality parameters in public primary schools. Multidiscip Respir Med 2019;14:1-7.
16. Ahmednur M, Awel H, Haile G. Microbial indoor air quality and associated factors in Jimma Town Prison -Administration, Southwestern Ethiopia. Environ Health Insights 2022;16:11786302221118842.
17. Troeger C, Blacker B, Khalil IA, Rao PC, Cao J, Zimsen SR, et al. Estimates of the global, regional, and national morbidity, mortality, and aetiologies of lower respiratory infections in 195 countries, 1990–2016: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2016. Lancet Infect Dis 2018;18:1191-210.
18. Wardlaw TM, Johansson EW, Hodge MJ. Pneumonia: the forgotten killer of children. New York: UNICEF; 2006.
19. Abdel-Aziz RA, Radwan SM. Microbial pollution of indoor air in Riyadh city government schools. World J Adv Res Rev 2020;8:209-16.
20. Hayleeyesus SF, Ejeso A, Derseh FA. Quantitative assessment of bio-aerosols contamination in indoor air of university dormitory rooms. Int J Health Sci 2015;9:249.
21. Belay G, Gelaw B, Tigabu A, Raju R. Indoor bacterial pollution, antimicrobial susceptibility patterns and associated risk factors of bacterial isolates among residences of Gondar town, Northwest Ethiopia. World J Indoor Built Environ 2021;30:1766-80.
22. Girma A, Lamore Y. Determination of the indoor air bacterial profile in Jimma University Specialized Hospital, Southwest Ethiopia. SAGE Open Med 2022;10:20503121221122405.
23. Solomon FB, Wadilo FW, Arota AA, Abraham YL. Antibiotic resistant airborne bacteria and their multidrug resistance pattern at University teaching referral hospital in South Ethiopia. Ann Clin Microbiol Antimicrob 2017;16:1-7.
24. Kayta G, Manilal A, Tadesse D, Siraj M. Indoor air microbial load, antibiotic susceptibility profiles of bacteria, and associated factors in different wards of Arba Minch General Hospital, Southern Ethiopia. PLoS One 2022;17:e0271022.
25. Leta D, Aragaw K, Merid Y. Identification, characterization and antibiotic susceptibility of indoor airborne bacteria in selected wards of Hawassa University Teaching and Referral Hospital, South Ethiopia. Open Access Libr Preprints 2014;1:1-12.
26. Hawassa City Education Office. Number of students enrolled in Hawassa city private and government primary schools from grade 1–8. Hawassa, Ethiopia: HCEO; 2023.
27. Zhang C. Fundamentals of environmental sampling and analysis. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons; 2024.
28. Manly BF. Statistics for environmental science and management. Boca Raton: Chapman and Hall/CRC; 2008.
29. Omeliansky V. Manual in microbiology. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences; 1940.
30. Cheesbrough M. District laboratory practice in tropical countries. Part 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2005.
31. Cheesbrough M. Medical laboratory manual for tropical countries. Vol. 1. Cambridge: Tropical Health Technology; 1981.
32. Wanner HU, Gravesen S. Biological particles in indoor environments: European Collaborative Action. Indoor Air Quality & Its Impact on Man. Brussels: European Commission; 1993.
33. Hilu D, Faris K, Adimassu M, Tassew S. Housing and institutional health. Lecture Notes. Hawassa: Hawassa University; 2002.
34. Meleko A, Henok A, Tefera W, Lamaro T. Assessment of the sanitary conditions of catering establishments and food safety knowledge and practices of food handlers in Addis Ababa University students’ cafeteria. Science 2015;3:733-43.
35. Aeroqual. Series 200, 300, 500 Portable Monitor User Guide. Auckland: Aeroqual; 2014.
36. Murugalatha N, Growther L, Hena JV, Shenpagam NH, Anitha R, Devi DK, et al. Microbiological techniques. Chennai: MJP Publisher; 2022.
37. Sapkota A. Laminar flow hood/cabinet: parts, principle, types, uses. Microbe Notes 2024. Available from: https:/microbenotes.com/laminar-flow-hood
38. Chalvatzaki E, Chatoutsidou SE, Martins V, Faria T, Diapouli E, Manousakas M, et al. Assessment of the personal dose received by school children due to PM10 air pollution in Lisbon. Aerosol Air Qual Res 2020;20:1384-97.
39. Roshaliha R, Tejamaya M. Profile of bioaerosol contaminants in primary school classrooms: systematic literature review 2016–2020. In: Proceedings of the 11th Annual International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management (IEOM 2021); Singapore; 2021. 5474-85.
40. Andualem Z, Gizaw Z, Bogale L, Dagne H. Indoor bacterial load and its correlation to physical indoor air quality parameters in public primary schools. Multidiscip Respir Med 2019;14:1-7.
41. Seong D, Norman RS, Hoque S. Influence of indoor conditions on microbial diversity and quantity in schools. In: Proceedings of the 13th REHVA World Congress CLIMA 2019; Bucharest, Romania; 2019. E3S Web Conf 2019;111:01035.
42. Mentese S, Rad AY, Arısoy M, Güllü G. Seasonal and spatial variations of bioaerosols in indoor urban environments, Ankara, Turkey. Indoor Built Environ 2012;21:797-810.
43. Naruka K, Gaur J. Microbial air contamination in a school. Int J Curr Microbiol Appl Sci 2013;2:404-10.
44. Brgoszewska E, Mainka A, Pastuszka JS. Concentration and size distribution of culturable bacteria in ambient air during spring and winter in Gliwice: a typical urban area. Atmosphere 2017;8:239.
45. Hazrin A, Maryam Z, Hizrri A, Norhidayah A, Samsuddin N, Mohd Shukri M. Occupancy implications on indoor air quality (IAQ) in selected primary school classrooms around Kuantan, Pahang. Malays J Public Health Med 2016.
46. Madureira J, Aguiar L, Pereira C, Mendes A, Querido MM, Neves P, et al. Indoor exposure to bioaerosol particles: levels and implications for inhalation dose rates in schoolchildren. Air Qual Atmos Health 2018;11:955-64.
47. Kembel SW, Meadow JF, O’Connor TK, Mhuireach G, Northcutt D, Kline J, et al. Architectural design drives the biogeography of indoor bacterial communities. PLoS One 2014;9:e87093.
48. Abebe H. Indoor air bacterial load and contributing factors in government and private hospitals in Harar, Harar town, Eastern Ethiopia. Addis Ababa: Addis Ababa University; 2017.
49. Awad AH, Saeed Y, Hassan Y, Fawzy Y, Osman M. Air microbial quality in certain public buildings, Egypt: a comparative study. Atmos Pollut Res 2018;9:617-26.
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 The Author(s)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Mattioli 1885 has chosen to apply the Creative Commons Attribution NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0) to all manuscripts to be published.
How to Cite
